Wednesday, December 16, 2009 - 1:30 p.m.

Present:

Alan R. Schriber, Chairman
Ronda Hartman Fergus, Commissioner
Valerie A. Lemmie, Commissioner
Paul A. Centolella, Commissioner
Cheryl L. Roberto, Commissioner
Paul J. Duffy, Legal Director
Kim Bojko, Electric Section, Legal Department
Christine Pirik, Gas Section, Legal Department
Scott Farkas, Transportation Section, Legal Department
Vesta Miller, Legal Department
 
 

This meeting was convened pursuant to the regular agenda issued on December 10, 2009, for the week of December 14, 2009.
 

The minutes of the December 9 and 11, 2009 Commission Meeting were approved by the Commissioners.
 

The Commission met for the purpose of considering the following cases and to act upon the proposed Entries and/or Opinions and Orders.

Signing Session: December 16, 2009 at 1:38 p.m. 

 

Resolution Proclaiming
Ron Rose
as Chuck Tingley Employee
of the Month for December

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.
 

All Utilities:

09-01-AU-UNC

Annual Reports for Calendar Year 2008 by Regulated Public Utilities, Railroads and Service Providers
(Entry considering sanctions for failure to file)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

Electric:

Tariffs:

(09-872-EL-FAC
(09-873-EL-FAC
(09-1906-EL-ATA

Columbus Southern Power Company
Ohio Power Company
Columbus Southern Power Company and Ohio Power Company
(Finding and order considering tariff modifications)

Rescheduled to appear on January 7, 2010 agenda.

09-541-EL-ATA

Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company
(Finding and order considering application)

Rescheduled to appear on January 7, 2010 agenda.

09-968-EL-ATA

Ohio Edison Company, The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company, and The Toledo Edison Company
(Finding and order considering application)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

Others:

08-613-EL-UNC

Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
(Entry considering request to withdraw application to amend)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

09-463-EL-UNC

Ohio Department of Development
(Opinion and order considering USF rider adjustment stipulation)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

09-864-EL-CSS

Charles F. Carr v. The Toledo Edison Company
(Entry considering dismissal of complaint)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0. 

09-770-EL-RDR

Duke Energy Ohio, Inc.
(Consideration of opinion and order)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

09-714-EL-UNC

Adoption of a Portfolio Plan Template for Electric Utility Energy Efficiency and Peak-Demand Reduction Programs
(Finding and order considering adoption of portfolio plan template)

Stricken from the December 16, 2009 agenda.

(09-578-EL-EEC
(09-579-EL-EEC

Columbus Southern Power Company
Ohio Power Company
(Entry considering peak demand reduction program and porfolio plan and benchmarks)

Stricken from the December 16, 2009 agenda.

(09-987-EL-EEC
(09-988-EL-EEC

Columbus Southern Power Company
Ohio Power Company
(Entry considering solar energy resource benchmarks)

Rescheduled to appear on January 7, 2010 agenda.

(09-384-EL-EEC
(09-385-EL-EEC
(09-386-EL-EEC

Ohio Edison Company
The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company
The Toledo Edison Company
(Finding and order considering application)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

(09-1004-EL-EEC
(09-1005-EL-EEC
(09-1006-EL-EEC

Ohio Edison Company
The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company
The Toledo Edison Company
(Finding and order considering application)

Rescheduled to appear on January 7, 2010 agenda.

(09-984-EL-AIS
(09-1013-EL-AIS
(09-1014-EL-AIS
(09-1015-EL-AIS

American Transmission Systems Incorporated
The Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company
The Toledo Edison Company
Ohio Edison Company
(Finding and order considering requests to issue short-term debt)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0. 

09-1012-EL-UNC

The Dayton Power and Light Company
(Entry considering application)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

09-1095-EL-RDR

Columbus Southern Power Company and Ohio Power Company
(Finding and order considering economic development cost recovery rider)

Rescheduled to appear on January 7, 2010 agenda.

09-694-EL-REN

Summersville Hydroelectric Project
(Finding and order considering certificate issuance)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

09-663-EL-REN

Krayn Wind LLC
(Finding and order considering certificate issuance)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

09-1029-EL-REN

Leichter
(Finding and order considering certificate issuance)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

09-1049-EL-REN

E. Roberts Solar Array
(Finding and order considering certificate issuance)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

09-1072-EL-REN

Blais
(Finding and order considering certificate issuance)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0. 
   
     

09-1073-EL-REN

Bunnell
(Finding and order considering certificate issuance)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

09-1074-EL-REN

Comey
(Finding and order considering certificate issuance)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

09-1075-EL-REN

Eby
(Finding and order considering certificate issuance)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.
   

09-1076-EL-REN

Edleman
(Finding and order considering certificate issuance)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

09-1077-EL-REN

Erdman
(Finding and order considering certificate issuance)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

09-1078-EL-REN

Hoover
(Finding and order considering certificate issuance)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

09-1079-EL-REN

Lindsey
(Finding and order considering certificate issuance)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0. 

09-1080-EL-REN

Rubinger
(Finding and order considering certificate issuance)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

09-1091-EL-REN

Fowler Ridge Wind Farm LLC
(Finding and order considering certificate issuance)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

Gas:

09-458-GA-RDR

East Ohio Gas Company d/b/a Dominion East Ohio
(Consideration of opinion and order)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

09-1862-GA-AIR

Piedmont Gas Company
(Entry considering test year and date certain proposals)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.
  

Transportation:

Rehearings:

09-125-RR-UNC

CSX Transportation/Ulsh Road
(Entry considering application for rehearing)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

Others:

07-1028-RR-UNC

CSX Transportation, Inc./Wood County
(Entry considering request for extension of crossing projects)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

09-1880-RR-FED

Norfolk Southern Railway/Erie County
(Entry considering grade crossing projects)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

09-1909-TR-CVF

PUCO/J Garner Transportation
(Finding and order considering settlement agreement)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.

09-1928-TR-ORD

Amendment of Chapter 4901:2-5, Ohio Administrative Code
(Entry considering Emergency Rule 4901:2-5-05)

Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.
  

Resolution:

Resolution honoring Joan Sant upon her retirement after covering Commission meetings for 32 years for the law firm of Porter Wright Morris & Arthur.  Approval moved and seconded, vote 5-0.
 

There being no further business, the Commission Meeting adjourned at approximately 2:01 p.m.

 

June 5, 2013
Commission Minutes June 5, 2013
May 29, 2013
Commission Minutes May 29, 2013
May 22, 2013
Commission Minutes May 22, 2013
May 15, 2013
Commission Minutes May 15, 2013
May 1, 2013
Commission Minutes May 1, 2013
April 24, 2013
Commission Minutes April 24, 2013
April 10, 2013
Commission Minutes April 10, 2013
April 3, 2013
Commission Minutes April 3, 2013
March 20, 2013
Commission Minutes March 20, 2013
March 13, 2013
Commission Minutes March 13, 2013
March 6, 2013
Commission Minutes March 6, 2013
February 27, 2013
Commission Minutes February 27, 2013
February 19, 2013
Commission Minutes February 19, 2013
February 13, 2013
Commission Minutes February 13, 2013
January 30, 2013
Commission Minutes January 30, 2013
January 23, 2013
Commission Minutes January 23, 2013
January 16, 2013
Commission Minutes January 16, 2013
January 9, 2013
Commission Minutes January 9, 2013
December 19, 2012
Commission Minutes December 19, 2012
December 12, 2012
Commission Minutes December 12, 2012
November 16, 2012
Commission Minutes November 16, 2012
November 7, 2012
Commission Minutes November 7, 2012
October 31, 2012
Commission Minutes October 31, 2012
October 17, 2012
Commission Meeting Minutes October 17, 2012
October 10, 2012
Commission Meeting Minutes October 10, 2012
October 3, 2012
Commission Meeting Minutes October 3, 2012
September 26, 2012
Commission Meeting Minutes September 26, 2012
September 19, 2012
Commission Minutes September 19, 2012
September 12, 2012
Commission Meeting Minutes September 12, 2012
September 5, 2012
Commission Meeting Minutes September 5, 2012
August 29, 2012
Commission Meeting Minutes August 29, 2012
August 22, 2012
Commission Meeting Minutes August 22, 2012
August 15, 2012
Commission Minutes August 15, 2012
August 8, 2012
Commission Meeting August 8, 2012
August 1, 2012
Commission Minutes August 1, 2012
July 18, 2012
Commission Minutes July 18, 2012
July 11, 2012
Commission Meeting July 11, 2012
July 2, 2012
Commission Minutes July 2, 2012
June 20, 2012
Commission Minutes June 20, 2012
June 13, 2012
Commission Minutes June 13, 2012
June 6, 2012
Commission Minutes June 6, 2012
May 30, 2012
Commission Minutes May 30, 2012
May 23, 2012
Commission Minutes May 23, 2012
May 16, 2012
Commission Minutes May 16, 2012
May 9, 2012
Commission Minutes May 9, 2012
May 2, 2012
Commission Minutes May 2, 2012
April 25, 2012
Commission Minutes April 25, 2012
April 18, 2012
Commission Meeting April 18, 2012
April 11, 2012
Commission Minutes April 11, 2012
March 28, 2012
Commission Minutes March 28, 2012
March 21, 2012
Commission Minutes March 21, 2012
March 14, 2012
Commission Minutes March 14, 2012
March 7, 2012
Commission Minutes March 7, 2012
February 29, 2012
Commission Minutes February 29, 2012
February 23, 2012
Commission Minutes February 23, 2012
February 14, 2012
Commission Minutes February 14, 2012
February 1, 2012
Commission Minutes February 1, 2012
January 26, 2012
Commission Minutes January 26, 2012
January 23, 2012
Commission Minutes January 23, 2012
January 18, 2012
Commission Minutes January 18, 2012
January 11, 2012
Commission Minutes January 11, 2012
January 4, 2012
Commission Minutes January 4, 2012
December 15, 2011
Commission Minutes December 15, 2011
December 14, 2011
Commission Minutes December 14, 2011
December 7, 2011
Commission Minutes December 7, 2011
November 29, 2011
Commission Minutes November 29, 2011
November 22, 2011
Commission Minutes November 22, 2011
November 9, 2011
Commission Minutes November 9, 2011
November 1, 2011
Commission Minutes November 1, 2011
October 26, 2011
Commission Minutes October 26, 2011
October 18, 2011
Commission Minutes October 18, 2011
October 12, 2011
Commission Meeting Minutes October 12, 2011
October 3, 2011
Commission Meeting Minutes October 3, 2011
September 20, 2011
Commission Meeting Minutes September 20, 2011
September 19, 2011
Commission Meeting Minutes September 19, 2011
September 14, 2011
Commission Minutes September 14, 2011
September 7, 2011
Commission Meeting September 7, 2011
August 31, 2011
Commission Meeting Minutes August 31, 2011
August 24, 2011
Commission Meeting Minutes August 24, 2011
August 17, 2011
Commission Minutes August 17, 2011
August 3, 2011
Commission Minutes August 3, 2011
July 27, 2011
Commission Minutes July 27, 2011
July 15, 2011
Commission Minutes July 15, 2011
July 6, 2011
Commission Meeting July 6, 2011
June 29, 2011
Commission Meeting June 29, 2011
June 22, 2011
Commission Meeting June 22, 2011
June 15, 2011
Commission Meeting June 15, 2011
June 8, 2011
Commission Meeting June 8, 2011
June 1, 2011
Commission Meeting June 1, 2011
May 25, 2011
Commission Meeting May 25, 2011
May 19, 2011
Commission Meeting May 19, 2011
May 4, 2011
Commission Meeting May 4, 2011
April 27, 2011
Commission Meeting April 27, 2011
April 19, 2011
Commission Meeting April 19, 2011
April 13, 2011
Commission Meeting April 13, 2011
April 5, 2011
Commission Meeting April 5, 2011
March 30, 2011
Commission Meeting March 30, 2011
March 23, 2011
Commission Meeting March 23, 2011
March 16, 2011
Commission Meeting March 16, 2011
March 9, 2011
Commission Meeting March 9, 2011
March 2, 2011
Commission Meeting March 2, 2011
February 23, 2011
Commission Meeting February 23, 2011
February 16, 2011
No Commission Meeting week of February 14, 2011
February 9, 2011 Minutes
February 2, 2011 Minutes
January 27, 2011 Minutes
January 19, 2011 Minutes
January 11, 2011 Minutes
January 5, 2011 Minutes
December 29, 2010 Minutes
December 21, 2010 Minutes
December 15, 2010 Minutes
December 8, 2010 Minutes
December 1, 2010 Minutes
November 22, 2010 Minutes
November 10, 2010 Minutes
November 3, 2010 Minutes
October 27, 2010 Minutes
October 22, 2010 Minutes
October 15, 2010 Minutes
October 4, 2010 Minutes
September 29, 2010 Minutes
September 22, 2010 Minutes
September 15, 2010 Minutes
September 8, 2010 Minutes
September 1, 2010 Minutes
August 25, 2010 Minutes
August 18, 2010 Minutes
August 11, 2010 Minutes
August 4, 2010 Minutes
July 29, 2010 Minutes
July 14, 2010 Minutes
June 30, 2010 Minutes
June 23, 2010 Minutes
June 16, 2010 Minutes
June 9, 2010 Minutes
June 2, 2010 Minutes
May 26, 2010 Minutes
May 19, 2010 Minutes
May 13, 2010 Minutes
May 5, 2010 Minutes
April 28, 2010 Minutes
April 15, 2010 Minutes
April 14, 2010 Minutes
April 6, 2010 Minutes
March 31, 2010 Minutes
March 24, 2010 Minutes
March 17, 2010 Minutes
March 10, 2010 Minutes
March 3, 2010 Minutes
February 24, 2010 Minutes
February 11, 2010 Minutes
February 3, 2010 Minutes
January 27, 2010 Minutes
January 20, 2010 Minutes
January 13, 2010 Minutes
January 7, 2010 Minutes
December 16, 2009 Minutes
December 11, 2009 Minutes
December 9, 2009 Minutes
December 2, 2009 Minutes
November 24, 2009 Minutes
November 18, 2009 Minutes
November 12, 2009 Minutes
November 4, 2009 Minutes
October 28, 2009 Minutes
October 15, 2009 Minutes
October 14, 2009 Minutes
October 7, 2009 Minutes
September 30, 2009 Minutes
September 23, 2009 Minutes
September 15, 2009 Minutes
September 9, 2009 Minutes
September 2, 2009 Minutes
August 26, 2009 Minutes
August 19, 2009 Minutes
August 12, 2009 Minutes
July 29, 2009 Minutes
July 23, 2009 Minutes
July 15, 2009 Minutes
July 8, 2009 Minutes
July 1, 2009 Minutes
June 24, 2009 Minutes
June 17, 2009 Minutes
June 10, 2009 Minutes
June 3, 2009 Minutes
May 27, 2009 Minutes
May 21, 2009 Minutes
May 14, 2009 Minutes
May 13, 2009 Minutes
May 6, 2009 Minutes
April 29, 2009 Minutes
April 22, 2009 Minutes
April 15, 2009 Minutes
April 8, 2009 Minutes
April 1, 2009 Minutes
March 30, 2009 Minutes
March 25, 2009 Minutes
March 18, 2009 Minutes
March 10, 2009 Minutes
March 4, 2009 Minutes
February 25, 2009 Minutes
February 19, 2009 Minutes
February 11, 2009 Minutes
February 4, 2009 Minutes
January 29, 2009 Minutes
January 21, 2009 Minutes
January 14, 2009 Minutes
January 7, 2009 Minutes
December 19, 2008 Minutes
December 17, 2008 Minutes
December 10, 2008 Minutes
December 3, 2008 Minutes
November 25, 2008 Minutes
November 19, 2008 Minutes
November 12, 2008 Minutes
November 5, 2008 Minutes
October 29, 2008 Minutes
October 22, 2008 Minutes
October 15, 2008 Minutes
October 08, 2008 Minutes
October 1, 2008 Minutes
September 17, 2008 Minutes
September 10, 2008 Minutes
September 3, 2008 Minutes
August 27, 2008 Minutes
August 20, 2008 Minutes
August 13, 2008 Minutes
July 31, 2008 Minutes
July 23, 2008 Minutes
July 16, 2008 Minutes
July 9, 2008 Minutes
July 2, 2008 Minutes
June 25, 2008 Minutes
June 18, 2008 Minutes
June 11, 2008 Minutes
June 4, 2008 Minutes
May 28, 2008 Minutes
May 14, 2008 Minutes
May 7, 2008 Minutes
April 30, 2008 Minutes
April 23, 2008 Minutes
April 16, 2008 Minutes
April 9, 2008 Minutes
April 2, 2008 Minutes
March 26, 2008 Minutes
March 19, 2008 Minutes
March 12, 2008 Minutes
March 5, 2008 Minutes
February 27, 2008 Minutes
February 13, 2008 Minutes
February 5, 2008 Minutes
January 30, 2008 Minutes
January 23, 2008 Minutes
January 16, 2008 Minutes
January 9, 2008 Minutes
December 19, 2007 Minutes
December 12, 2007 Minutes
December 5, 2007 Minutes
November 28, 2007 Minutes
November 20, 2007 Minutes
November 7, 2007 Minutes
October 31, 2007 Minutes
October 24, 2007 Minutes
October 17, 2007 Minutes
October 10, 2007 Minutes
October 3, 2007 Minutes
September 26, 2007 Minutes
September 19, 2007 Minutes
September 5, 2007 Minutes
August 29, 2007 Minutes
August 22, 2007 Minutes
July 25, 2007 Minutes
July 11, 2007 Minutes
June 27, 2007 Minutes
June 13, 2007 Minutes
June 6, 2007 Minutes
May 30, 2007 Minutes
May 24, 2007 Minutes
May 16, 2007 Minutes
May 9, 2007 Minutes
May 2, 2007 Minutes
April 25, 2007 Minutes
April 18, 2007 Minutes
April 11, 2007 Minutes
April 4, 2007 Minutes
March 28, 2007 Minutes
March 21, 2007 Minutes
March 14, 2007 Minutes
March 7, 2007 Minutes
February 28, 2007 Minutes
February 14, 2007 Minutes
February 7, 2007 Minutes
January 31, 2007 Minutes
January 24, 2007 Minutes
January 17, 2007 Minutes
January 10, 2007 Minutes
January 3, 2007 Minutes
December 20, 2006 Minutes
December 13, 2006 Minutes
December 6, 2006 Minutes
November 28, 2006 Minutes
November 21, 2006 Minutes
November 8, 2006 Minutes
November 1, 2006 Minutes
October 25, 2006 Minutes
October 18, 2006
October 11, 2006 Minutes
October 4, 2006 Minutes
September 20, 2006 Minutes
September 13, 2006 Minutes
September 6, 2006 Minutes
August 30, 2006 Minutes
August 23, 2006
August 16, 2006 Minutes
August 9, 2006 Minutes
July 26, 2006 Minutes
July 12, 2006 Minutes
June 28, 2006 Minutes
June 22, 2006 Minutes
June 14, 2006 Minutes
June 6, 2006 Minutes
May 31, 2006 Minutes
May 26, 2006 Minutes
May 16, 2006 Minutes
May 10, 2006 Minutes
May 3, 2006 Minutes
April 26, 2006 Minutes
April 19, 2006 Minutes
April 10, 2006 Minutes
April 5, 2006 Minutes
March 29, 2006 Minutes
March 20, 2006 Minutes
March 15, 2006
March 7, 2006 Minutes
March 1, 2006 Minutes
February 22, 2006 Minutes
February 6, 2006 Minutes
February 1, 2006 Minutes
January 25, 2006 Minutes
January 18, 2006 Minutes
January 11, 2006 Minutes
January 4, 2006 Minutes
December 28, 2005
December 21, 2005 Minutes
December 14, 2005 Minutes
December 7, 2005 Minutes
November 29, 2005 Minutes
November 22, 2005 Minutes
November 4, 2005 Minutes
October 26, 2005 Minutes
October 19, 2005 Minutes
October 12, 2005 Minutes
October 5, 2005 Minutes
September 28, 2005 Minutes
September 21, 2005 Minutes
September 14, 2005 Minutes
September 7, 2005 Minutes
August 31, 2005 Minutes
August 24, 2005 Minutes
August 17, 2005 Minutes
August 10, 2005 Minutes
August 3, 2005 Minutes
July 19, 2005 Minutes
July 13, 2005 Minutes
July 6, 2005 Minutes
July 6, 2005 Minutes
June 29, 2005 Minutes
June 14, 2005 Minutes
June 8, 2005 Minutes
June 1, 2005 Minutes
May 18, 2005 Minutes
May 11, 2005 Minutes
May 4, 2005 Minutes
April 27, 2005 Minutes
April 20, 2005 Minutes
April 13, 2005 Minutes
April 6, 2005 Minutes
April 6, 2005 Minutes
March 23, 2005 Minutes
March 16, 2005 Minutes
March 9, 2005 Minutes
March 2, 2005 Minutes
February 23, 2005 Minutes
February 9, 2005 Minutes
February 2, 2005 Minutes
January 26, 2005 Minutes
January 19, 2005 Minutes
January 12, 2005 Minutes
January 5, 2005 Minutes
December 21, 2004 Minutes
December 15, 2004 Minutes
December 9, 2004 Minutes
December 8, 2004 Minutes
December 1, 2004 Minutes
November 23, 2004 Minutes
November 10, 2004 Minutes
November 3, 2004 Minutes
October 27, 2004 Minutes
October 20, 2004 Minutes
October 13, 2004 Minutes
October 6, 2004 Minutes
September 29, 2004 Minutes
September 22, 2004 Minutes
September 15, 2004 Minutes
September 1, 2004 Minutes
August 25, 2004 Minutes
August 18, 2004 Minutes
August 11, 2004 Minutes
August 4, 2004 Minutes
July 28, 2004 Minutes
July 20, 2004 Minutes
July 7, 2004 Minutes
June 23, 2004 Minutes
June 16, 2004 Minutes
June 9, 2004 Minutes
June 2, 2004 Minutes
May 27, 2004 Minutes
May 19, 2004 Minutes
May 12, 2004 Minutes
May 5, 2004 Minutes
April 29, 2004 Minutes
April 21, 2004 Minutes
April 14, 2004 Minutes
April 7, 2004 Minutes
March 30, 2004 Minutes
March 25, 2004 Minutes
March 17, 2004 Minutes
March 11, 2004 Minutes
March 4, 2004 Minutes
February 26, 2004 Minutes
February 19, 2004 Minutes
February 11, 2004 Minutes
February 4, 2004 Minutes
January 21, 2004 Minutes
January 14, 2004 Minutes
January 7, 2004 Minutes
December 17, 2003 Minutes
December 9, 2003 Minutes
December 3, 2003 Minutes
November 25, 2003 minutes
November 12, 2003 Minutes
November 6, 2003 Minutes
October 28, 2003 Minutes
October 22, 2003 Minutes
October 15, 2003 Minutes
October 7, 2003 Minutes
October 2, 2003 Minutes
September 23, 2003 Minutes
September 18, 2003 Minutes
September 11, 2003 Minutes
September 2, 2003 Minutes
August 26 & 28, 2003 Minutes
August 19, 2003 Minutes
August 12 & 14, 2003 Minutes
August 6, 2003 Minutes
July 15, 2003 Minutes
July 8, 2003 Minutes
July 1, 2003 Minutes
July 22 & 24, 2003 Minutes
June 17 & 19, 2003 Minutes